The effective power of the Provisional Government was challenged by
the authority of an institution that claimed to represent the will of
workers and soldiers and could, in fact, mobilize and control these
groups during the early months of the revolution – the Petrograd Soviet
[Council] of Workers' Deputies. The model for the soviet were workers'
councils that had been established in scores of Russian cities during
the 1905 Revolution. In February 1917, striking workers elected deputies
to represent them and socialist activists began organizing a citywide
council to unite these deputies with representatives of the socialist
parties. On 27 February, socialist Duma deputies, mainly
Mensheviks and Socialist Revolutionaries, took the lead in organizing a citywide council. The Petrograd Soviet met in the
Tauride Palace, the same building where the new government was taking shape.
The leaders of the Petrograd Soviet believed that they represented
particular classes of the population, not the whole nation. They also
believed Russia was not ready for socialism. So they saw their role as
limited to pressuring hesitant "bourgeoisie" to rule and to introduce
extensive democratic reforms in Russia (the replacement of the monarchy
by a republic, guaranteed civil rights, a democratic police and army,
abolition of religious and ethnic discrimination, preparation of
elections to a constituent assembly, and so on).
[21]
They met in the same building as the emerging Provisional Government
not to compete with the Duma Committee for state power but to best exert
pressure on the new government, to act, in other words, as a popular
democratic lobby.
The relationship between these two major powers was complex from the
beginning and would shape the politics of 1917. The representatives of
the Provisional Government agreed to "take into account the opinions of
the Soviet of Workers' Deputies", though they were also determined to
prevent "interference in the actions of the government", which would
create "an unacceptable situation of dual power."
[22]
In fact, this was precisely what was being created, though this "dual
power" (dvoevlastie) was the result less of the actions or attitudes of
the leaders of these two institutions than of actions outside their
control, especially the ongoing social movement taking place on the
streets of Russia’s cities, in factories and shops, in barracks and in
the trenches, and in the villages.
The 2nd Moscow Women Death Battalion protecting the Winter Palace as the last guards of the stronghold.
A series of political crises – see the chronology below – in the
relationship between population and government and between the
Provisional Government and the soviets (which developed into a
nationwide movement with a national leadership, The All-Russian Central
Executive Committee of Soviets (VTsIK)) undermined the authority of the
Provisional Government but also of the moderate socialist leaders of the
Soviet. Although the Soviet leadership initially refused to participate
in the "bourgeois" Provisional Government,
Alexander Kerensky, a young and popular lawyer and a member of the
Socialist Revolutionary Party
(SRP), agreed to join the new cabinet, and became an increasingly
central figure in the government, eventually taking leadership of the
Provisional Government. As minister of war and later Prime Minister,
Kerensky promoted freedom of speech, released thousands of political
prisoners, did his very best to continue the war effort and even
organised another offensive (which, however, was no more successful than
its predecessors). Nevertheless, Kerensky still faced several great
challenges, highlighted by the soldiers, urban workers and peasants, who
claimed that they had gained nothing by the revolution:
- Other political groups were trying to undermine him.
- Heavy military losses were being suffered on the front.
- The soldiers were dissatisfied and demoralised and had started to
defect. (On arrival back in Russia, these soldiers were either
imprisoned or sent straight back into the front.)
- There was enormous discontent with Russia's involvement in the war, and many were calling for an end to it.
- There were great shortages of food and supplies, which was difficult to remedy because of the wartime economic conditions.
The political group that proved most troublesome for Kerensky, and
would eventually overthrow him, was the Bolshevik Party, led by
Vladimir Lenin.
Lenin had been living in exile in neutral Switzerland and, due to
democratization of politics after the February Revolution, which
legalized formerly banned political parties, he perceived the
opportunity for his Marxist revolution. Although return to Russia had
become a possibility, the war made it logistically difficult.
Eventually, German officials arranged for Lenin to pass through their
territory, hoping that his activities would weaken Russia or even – if
the Bolsheviks came to power – lead to Russia's withdrawal from the war.
Lenin and his associates, however, had to agree to travel to Russia in a
sealed train: Germany would not take the chance that he would foment
revolution in Germany. After passing through the front, he arrived in
Petrograd in April 1917.
Street demonstration on
Nevsky Prospekt in
Petrograd just after troops of the Provisional Government opened fire in the July Days
With Lenin's arrival, the popularity of the
Bolsheviks
increased steadily. Over the course of the spring, public
dissatisfaction with the Provisional Government and the war, in
particular among workers, soldiers and peasants, pushed these groups to
radical parties. Despite growing support for the Bolsheviks, buoyed by
maxims that called most famously for "all power to the Soviets," the
party held very little real power in the moderate-dominated Petrograd
Soviet. In fact, historians such as Sheila Fitzpatrick have asserted
that Lenin's exhortations for the Soviet Council to take power were
intended to arouse indignation both with the Provisional Government,
whose policies were viewed as conservative, and the Soviet itself, which
was viewed as subservient to the conservative government. By some
historians' accounts, Lenin and his followers were unprepared for how
their groundswell of support, especially among influential worker and
soldier groups, would translate into real power in the summer of 1917.
Soviets attacking the Czar's police in the early days of the March Revolution
On 18 June, the Provisional Government launched an attack against
Germany that failed miserably. Soon after, the government ordered
soldiers to go to the front, reneging on a promise. The soldiers refused
to follow the new orders. The arrival of radical
Kronstadt
sailors – who had tried and executed many officers, including one
admiral – further fueled the growing revolutionary atmosphere. The
sailors and soldiers, along with Petrograd workers, took to the streets
in violent protest, calling for "all power to the Soviets." The revolt,
however, was disowned by Lenin
[23] and the Bolshevik leaders and dissipated within a few days. In the aftermath, Lenin fled to
Finland under threat of arrest while
Trotsky, among other prominent Bolsheviks, was arrested. The
July Days
confirmed the popularity of the anti-war, radical Bolsheviks, but their
unpreparedness at the moment of revolt was an embarrassing gaffe that
lost them support among their main constituent groups: soldiers and
workers.
The Bolshevik failure in the July Days proved temporary. The
Bolsheviks had undergone a spectacular growth in membership. Whereas, in
February 1917, the Bolsheviks were limited to only 24,000 members, by
September 1917 there were 200,000 members of the Bolshevik faction.
[24]
Previously, the Bolsheviks had been in the minority in the two leading
cities of Russia—St. Petersburg and Moscow behind the Mensheviks and the
Socialist Revolutionaries, by September the Bolsheviks were in the
majority in both cities.
[25]
Furthermore, the Bolshevik-controlled Moscow Regional Bureau of the
Party also controlled the Party organizations of the thirteen (13)
provinces around Moscow. These thirteen provinces held 37% of Russia's
population and 20% of the membership of the Bolshevik faction.
[25]
In August, poor or misleading communication led General
Lavr Kornilov,
the recently appointed Supreme Commander of Russian military forces, to
believe that the Petrograd government had already been captured by
radicals, or was in serious danger thereof. In response, he ordered
troops to Petrograd to pacify the city. To secure his position, Kerensky
had to ask for Bolshevik assistance. He also sought help from the
Petrograd Soviet, which called upon armed Red Guards to "defend the
revolution". The
Kornilov Affair
failed largely due to the efforts of the Bolsheviks, whose influence
over railroad and telegraph workers proved vital in stopping the
movement of troops. With his coup failing, Kornilov surrendered and was
relieved of his position. The Bolsheviks' role in stopping the attempted
coup further strengthened their position.
In early September, the Petrograd Soviet freed all jailed Bolsheviks
and Trotsky became chairman of the Petrograd Soviet. Growing numbers of
socialists and lower-class Russians viewed the government less and less
as a force in support of their needs and interests. The Bolsheviks
benefited as the only major organized opposition party that had refused
to compromise with the Provisional Government, and they benefited from
growing frustration and even disgust with other parties, such as the
Mensheviks and Socialist Revolutionaries, who stubbornly refused to
break with the idea of national unity across all classes.
In Finland, Lenin had worked on his book
State and Revolution[26]
and continued to lead his party, writing newspaper articles and policy
decrees. By October, he returned to Petrograd (St. Petersburg), aware
that the increasingly radical city presented him no legal danger and a
second opportunity for revolution. Recognising the strength of the
Bolsheviks, Lenin began pressing for the immediate overthrow of the
Kerensky government by the Bolsheviks. Lenin was of the opinion that
taking power should occur in both St. Petersburg and Moscow
simultaneously, parenthetically stating that it made no difference which
city rose up first, but expressing his opinion that Moscow may well
rise up first.
[27]
The Bolshevik Central Committee drafted a resolution, calling for the
dissolution of the Provisional Government in favor of the Petrograd
Soviet. The resolution was passed 10–2 (
Lev Kamenev and
Grigory Zinoviev prominently dissenting) and the
October Revolution began.